All case studies Published

Building CivicScience's US sales team, nine Senior Sales Directors in two years

11Placements
9Senior Sales Directors
5Weeks average, brief to signed contract
What this search shows

CivicScience came to us in May 2024 with two briefs. Since then we have placed eleven people, nine of them Senior Sales Directors across agency and client-direct sales, in two hiring bursts averaging five weeks from brief to signed contract. None of it was exclusive. Every role was won against local US recruiters and CivicScience's own job ads, which is a fair test of whether a London-based search firm can deliver in the US.

Search lead
Matt Bolshaw
Founder

The business

CivicScience is a Pittsburgh-based advertising and analytics company. It collects over a million consumer survey responses a day and uses that declared, first-party data to plan, target and measure campaigns across display, online video, CTV and native. In 2024 it was building out a US sales team to take that proposition to agencies and brands.

The challenge

CivicScience first came to us through the CEO of its advertising business, who had worked with Matt at a previous company and drafted us in. Its US hiring had been going through local recruiters, and the terms were open from the start: contingent, non-exclusive, with CivicScience advertising the same roles itself. The harder challenge came later. Once the first few Senior Sales Directors were in seat, every new search had to find someone just as strong without going back to the people we had already spoken to.

The profile and the market

On paper the brief looked familiar: a senior individual contributor selling display, online video, CTV and native into agencies and brands. The difference was the proposition. CivicScience sells survey-based audiences and measurement alongside the media, and someone who has only ever sold impressions finds that hard to explain to a buyer. The people who did well had sold data before, whether that was identity, audience intelligence, search intent, location or contextual targeting, and most had spent time at a programmatic platform too. Nearly all of them were already Sales Directors or Senior Directors with fifteen years or more in the market, so the move was rarely about a bigger title.

That made for a small pool that overlapped heavily. Most of the strongest candidates had worked at the same handful of US data and programmatic businesses that every other growing Adtech company was hiring from, and placing the fifth or sixth Senior Sales Director meant widening the search each time rather than recycling the last shortlist. The team ended up mostly on the East Coast and the West Coast, with the occasional hire based elsewhere in the US where the right person happened to be.

Working with Matt and team was a game changer. They quickly understood our vision and helped us build a high performing GTM team with top tier talent. Their strategic approach, speed, and instinct for finding the right fit made all the difference.

Alex DeSanctis
Chief Revenue Officer, CivicScience

Ultimate Asset perspective

Most companies scaling a US sales team find the first few hires straightforward. The obvious candidates are easy to identify, and the difficulty tends to arrive around the fourth or fifth seat, when the shortlist starts repeating itself and the temptation is to lower the bar to keep the team growing. Avoiding that comes down to knowing the market well enough to keep finding new people, and having a clear view of what the role actually needs. For CivicScience that was a seller who could explain data to a buyer, and it was the standard we held to from the first hire to the eleventh.

Working without exclusivity, against local recruiters, kept us at the very top of our game, which is where we like to be. A London-based firm only earns the next US role by being quicker and better than the people down the road.

Related Building Hivestack's global leadership team
Contingent Search

Building a sales team in the US?

Talk us through the seats you need to fill and where they need to be, and we will give you an honest view of who is out there and what it will take to hire them.

For US Adtech searches, contact Matt Bolshaw, Founder.